Are index funds becoming too popular? Ben Johnson takes a closer look

 

 

09/03/2018

Robin Powell 

Ben Johnson – Morningstar 

RP: Hello there. Index funds are a very efficient way to invest. They allow ordinary investors to gain exposure to a large number of securities at very low cost. 

Passively managed funds have grown in popularity in recent years — so much so, in fact, that some argue we may be heading for an indexing bubble. So, is this something investors should be worried about? Ben Johnson, Director of Passive Funds Research at Morningstar, says not. 

BJ: If you look at the growth of passive investing, it’s clear why these concernes have been raised, because passive investing, index funds, exchange traded funds have been growing at a pace that has far outstripped the growth of traditionally actively managed funds. 

Now that said these are by definition very low activity managed funds. So the real concern should be, who is doing price setting at the margin? Does it continue to be well informed, well equipped active managers, or is ti just passive funds that are blindly buying securities that are setting out to track the index? 

These low activity, low turnover funds are actually doing a very tiny fraction of the actual trading in securities markets, which is where actual price discovery is taking place,where prices are being set. 

RP: Passive funds are still far less popular than active funds. But that’s changing fast. The ratings agency Moody’s has predicted that, in the US, passive could overtake active by 2021 — and will certainly do so 2024. 

But even then, Ben Johnson says there’ll be far more room for passive investing to grow without having to worry about any adverse effects on the markets. 

BJ: I would argue that passives can grow a fairly long way. They have a long runway from where they stand today before you might see any real, meaningful effect on price discovery, on capital formation, on the underlying securities prices. I think these fears, with respect to passives affect on the overall market are quite overblown. I think they are being fanned by frankly those who are threatened by them, whose territory is being encroached upon, which is high cost, high turnover active managers. 

RP: That’s all for now. Thank you to Ben Johnson, and to you, for watching. Until next time, goodbye. 

With all investments your capital is at risk and the value of your investments and the income deriving from it can rise as well as fall. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. This site is provided for information purposes only and is not intended as a recommendation or an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instruments. Robo-advisor is category established by U.S. companies like Betterment and Wealthfront, it does not imply we provide advice. Ask a Financial Advisor if in doubt. Amazon, Amundi, Apple, Barclays, Blackrock, Boost, Deutsche Bank, ETF Securities, First Trust, Google, HSBC, Invesco, Lyxor, SaxoBank, State Steet, Source, UBS, Ubuntu, Vanguard, Windows and Wisdom Tree are trademarks of their respective owners. ETFmatic Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (No. 657261) and is a limited liability company registered in England and Wales, no. 08856747, with a registered office at 4th Floor 7-10 Chandos Street, Cavendish Square, W1G 9DQ, London, United Kingdom. ETFmatic Ltd is registered for VAT with the HMRC with registration number 190 8981 63. The custodian of our clients money is Barclays Bank, while the ETF´s are held by Saxo Bank in a segregated account on the name of ETFmatic Global Nominee Ltd. Our services are available in Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and the United Kingdom. Free simulation accounts are available worldwide.

Secured By miniOrange